Living in Hilltop, Columbus: Homes, Rent, and Complaints

The Hilltop is the West Side area along West Broad Street and Sullivant Avenue that grew as a streetcar suburb around 1900. This site splits it into Central Hilltop and South Hilltop / Westgate.

About a third of the homes were built before 1940, and about half are rented. Most rentals are houses, not apartments. Homes cost less than in most of Columbus, and rent is a little lower. Encampment complaints, mostly people camping in tents, empty houses, garages, and alleys, come up more often than in most of Columbus.

What the homes are like in Hilltop

Hilltop is one of the older parts of Columbus. About a third of the homes here were built before 1940, against about 1 in 10 across Columbus. Most rentals here are single-family houses, while most renters across Columbus live in apartments.

HilltopColumbus
Rented 53% 56%
Single-family houses 72% 55%
Rentals that are houses 53% 27%
Built before 1940 33% 12%
Built before 1980 83% 50%
Renters paying 30%+ of income 56% 47%
Typical rent, with utilities
$1,150Columbus $1,300
Typical home value, owner estimate
$165,000Columbus $250,000

Census 2020–2024 medians in 2024 dollars: what people already living here paid or think their home is worth. Today’s listings usually ask more. Use these to compare places, not to budget.

All housing numbers for Hilltop

From the U.S. Census Bureau's American Community Survey, 2020–2024 five-year estimates, for the same map area as the reports on this page. These are survey estimates, rounded. Small areas have wider margins of error. * Low confidence: the survey’s margin of error is wide for this number here.

MeasureHilltopColumbus
Homes
Homes (housing units)19,000425,180
Rented53%56%
Lived in by the owner47%44%
Empty (any reason)10%8%
Empty and for rent3%2%
Empty and for sale0%*0%
Empty for other reasons6%4%
Buildings
Single-family houses72%55%
2 to 4 units10%13%
5 to 19 units12%20%
20 or more units4%12%
Mobile homes and other1%*1%
Rentals that are single-family houses53%27%
Age
Built before 194033%12%
Built 1940 to 197950%38%
Built 1980 to 199911%26%
Built 2000 or later6%24%
Typical year built19531980
Costs
Typical rent, with utilities$1,150$1,300
Renters spending 30%+ of income on rent56%47%
Renters spending 50%+ of income on rent33%23%
Typical home value (owner estimate)$165,000$250,000
Who stays
Renters who moved in 2020 or later44%50%
Owners who moved in before 201045%43%
Conditions
More than one person per room4%3%
Missing complete plumbing3%1%
Missing a complete kitchen3%2%

Renting or buying in Hilltop

Questions worth asking before you sign, based on the homes and the records here.

Lead paint
A little more than 8 in 10 homes here were built before 1980. Paint in homes built before 1978 can contain lead. Landlords and sellers must give you a lead disclosure form with the lease or contract. Ask for it.
Rented houses
Most rentals here are houses, not complexes. A rented house usually has no office on site. Ask who handles repairs, and how to reach them after hours.
Empty homes
About 1 in 16 homes here sits empty long term, well above the Columbus share. Check the houses next door too. Report a vacant building →
Older homes
About a third of the homes here are more than 80 years old. Ask how old the furnace and water heater are, and when the sewer line was last cleaned out.

What neighbors report in Hilltop

From 10,025 complaints filed with the city, January 2025 to October 2026.

Encampments
About 45 percent above the citywide rate.
Trend
About the same number of reports so far this year as the same months last year.
Spread
Problems are spread across the area. No single building or complex dominates, so check the exact address.
Season
Roach reports here peak in June. Across the rest of Columbus they peak in September.
Live map

See every complaint in Columbus on the map

About 84,500 complaints across the city, including 10,025 in Hilltop, plotted block by block. Filter by problem, search any address, or zoom in to any street.

Open live map ↗ HilltopAll other

How do reports in Hilltop compare with the rest of Columbus?

One row per complaint type: how its rate here compares with the citywide rate, whether it is rising or falling, and the month-by-month pattern.
Show the detailed stats for all 16 categories

Every category with at least 5 reports here. Category names link to the citywide guide.

Category vs citywide Trend · 2026 vs 2025 By month · Jan – Dec
Encampment
240 reports · 2.4% of all
1.5× → Steady January · 5%February · 3%March · 7%April · 6%May · 10%June · 13%July · 15%August · 11%September · 15%October · 11%November · 4%December · 1%
Trash
2,583 reports · 25.8% of all
1.2× ↓ Decreasing January · 6%February · 8%March · 14%April · 10%May · 9%June · 11%July · 10%August · 10%September · 10%October · 7%November · 3%December · 3%
Vacant Structure
826 reports · 8.2% of all
1.2× ↑ Increasing January · 7%February · 6%March · 10%April · 11%May · 12%June · 11%July · 10%August · 11%September · 9%October · 9%November · 2%December · 2%
Overgrowth
4,867 reports · 48.5% of all
1.1× → Steady January · 3%February · 4%March · 7%April · 9%May · 17%June · 16%July · 13%August · 12%September · 10%October · 6%November · 2%December · 2%
Vehicles
1,272 reports · 12.7% of all
1.1× → Steady January · 5%February · 8%March · 10%April · 11%May · 8%June · 12%July · 11%August · 9%September · 10%October · 9%November · 4%December · 4%
Rats
489 reports · 4.9% of all
1.01× ↑ Increasing January · 4%February · 5%March · 6%April · 11%May · 12%June · 15%July · 13%August · 11%September · 10%October · 8%November · 1%December · 3%
Sewage
89 reports · 0.9% of all
0.86× ↑ Increasing January · 19%February · 4%March · 10%April · 8%May · 12%June · 10%July · 18%August · 8%September · 6%October · 2%November · 1%December · 1%
Hoarding
15 reports · 0.1% of all
0.85× — —
Pest / Rodent
610 reports · 6.1% of all
0.85× → Steady January · 4%February · 5%March · 6%April · 10%May · 11%June · 16%July · 13%August · 12%September · 10%October · 7%November · 1%December · 3%
Safety
132 reports · 1.3% of all
0.77× ↑ Increasing January · 6%February · 4%March · 23%April · 8%May · 6%June · 8%July · 14%August · 10%September · 3%October · 8%November · 2%December · 7%
HVAC / Utilities
174 reports · 1.7% of all
0.72× → Steady January · 13%February · 8%March · 8%April · 10%May · 7%June · 7%July · 11%August · 8%September · 7%October · 6%November · 8%December · 7%
Roaches
47 reports · 0.5% of all
0.64× ↓ Decreasing January · 0%February · 2%March · 11%April · 6%May · 2%June · 21%July · 13%August · 19%September · 11%October · 4%November · 9%December · 2%
Noise
79 reports · 0.8% of all
0.60× — January · 3%February · 4%March · 19%April · 10%May · 16%June · 16%July · 9%August · 9%September · 5%October · 8%November · 1%December · 0%
Mold / Water Damage
168 reports · 1.7% of all
0.55× — January · 7%February · 3%March · 6%April · 10%May · 15%June · 10%July · 10%August · 17%September · 11%October · 8%November · 1%December · 4%
Landlord / Management
218 reports · 2.2% of all
0.54× ↑ Increasing January · 7%February · 5%March · 6%April · 9%May · 11%June · 10%July · 16%August · 16%September · 11%October · 6%November · 2%December · 2%
Bedbugs
9 reports · 0.1% of all
0.44× — —

Common questions about Hilltop

Short answers computed from the records on this page. Tap a question to read it.

What problems show up most in Hilltop's city records?

Higher than normal rate of encampment complaints.

Compared with the rest of Columbus, Hilltop sees more encampment reports than usual. The Census also counts more long-term empty homes here than across Columbus: about 1 in 16 homes, against about 1 in 25 citywide.

What is the housing like in Hilltop?

Hilltop is mostly older single-family houses, about half of them rented. About a third of the homes in Hilltop were built before 1940, against about 1 in 10 across Columbus. Most rentals in Hilltop are single-family houses, while most renters across Columbus live in apartments. In the 2020–2024 Census survey, the typical renter paid about $1,150 a month with utilities, against $1,300 across Columbus, and the typical owner valued their home at about $165,000, against $250,000. Those are what current residents paid or estimated over five years, not what listings ask today.

Which streets in Hilltop have the most complaints?

Ranked by complaints per address, the most-reported stretches are the 300 to 599 blocks of Catherine St, the 0 to 799 blocks of Whitethorne Ave, and the 2900 to 3399 blocks of Parkside Rd. 5 stretches stand out in total. Each one is roughly a hundred addresses, so check the exact address before drawing conclusions.

Tap a street to see it on the map.

Are the problems concentrated in a few buildings?

Problems here are spread across the area rather than concentrated. Reports come from over 4,200 different addresses, and no single building or complex dominates. The most-reported stretch is the 300 to 599 blocks of Catherine St, with 94 reports from 22 addresses. For any specific address, run a Block Report to see what has been reported there and next door.

Are reports in Hilltop going up or down?

They are steady. So far this year Hilltop has logged about the same number of reports as the same months last year.

All reports by month latest month: 328
328 JAN '25 OCT '26

How serious are the reports in Hilltop?

15% of the reports for Hilltop are rated severe or critical, such as sewage, no heat, mold, or an active infestation, against 16% citywide. That is about the same share as Columbus overall. The rest are moderate or low, like tall grass, trash, or a junk car.

Share of reports rated severe or critical, next to The parts of Hilltop and Columbus as a whole. Lower is calmer.

Hilltop15%
South Hilltop / Westgate14% Hilltop (core)17%
Columbus overall16%

Other Columbus areasLinden·West Side·Northland·Downtown·East Side·South Side

How do I report a problem in Hilltop?

Reports are what inspectors act on. If you see pests, mold, or no heat, report it to 311. It becomes part of the public record you're reading now. Safety complaints here peak in March. If that is your problem, report it when it starts. Do not wait for the busiest month.

What should landlords and property owners in Hilltop know?

Tenants in this area most often report encampment problems. Responding to tenant reports before they reach 311 keeps a property out of this dataset.

Is Hilltop safe?

This site does not track crime, so it cannot answer that. It tracks what residents report to the city about property and living conditions. Of the 10,025 records for Hilltop, 132 are safety complaints such as gas leaks, exposed wiring, or missing smoke detectors. For crime data, use the Columbus Division of Police. For one specific address, run a Block Report.

About Know Your Block

Know Your Block is a free public tool that shows what Columbus residents report to the city's code enforcement office: rats, mold, no heat, sewage backups, drug activity, noise, vacant buildings, and the other property and quality-of-life problems that a listing or a tour will not tell you about — the stuff Zillow and Apartments.com don't show. The live map plots every report in the city, and a Block Report checks one address, the building it sits in, and the block around it. This page and the other neighborhood pages are computed from the same records, so the numbers here match what you would find on the map. There is no account and no fee. More about the project.

Source & method

Data comes from official City of Columbus code enforcement records (Accela portal + ArcGIS REST API). Comparison figures are computed against the full citywide dataset; "above the citywide rate" means a category's share of complaints in this area is higher than its share citywide. Complaints are reports filed with the city — they may be unverified, resolved, or in dispute. Categories are assigned by automated keyword matching and may include mismatches. Individual property records are surfaced through search, not listed on this page. Housing figures come from the U.S. Census Bureau's American Community Survey (2020–2024 five-year estimates), split onto this page's map area by where each Census block's homes sit, so they cover the same ground as the reports. They describe homes, not people, and they are survey estimates with margins of error.